A thought about the prophecy - Likely Candidates.

[Phil Vlasak]

No: HPFGUIDX 97848


>Jen Snyder wrote:
> > ...the prophecy ...the part that says "...and either must die
> > at the hand of the other for neither can live while the other
> > survives...".
><>snipped>
> > What if "the other" is another person?
> >
> > ... interpreted as either Harry or Voldemort must die at the hand of
> > The Other (another person/being/force), ... neither ... live if this
> > other person/being/force is alive.
> >
<snipped>
 > Jen


>bboy_mn:
>
>I'm with you up to the point where Harry and Voldemort join forces
>against the unknown third party. Perhaps what it means it that this
>OTHER must make a moral choice, and in making that moral choice must
>decide if he will kill Harry or if he will kill Voldemort.
>
>Likely candidates- (for my theory)
>-Peter 'Wormtail' Pettigrew
>-Severus Snape
>-Lucius Malfoy
>-Draco Malfoy
>
><snipped>


>I will say this, I've thought from the very beginning, and continue to
>think, that this one live in the Prophecy holds the key to everything.
>
>Just a thought.
>
>bboy_mn

Phil responds,
I had a thought that the other would be Tom Riddle, possessed by the Dark Lord.
But I like your idea of Peter 'Wormtail' Pettigrew better...


>either Harry or Voldemort must die at the hand of Peter for neither can 
>live while Peter survives..
Since Peter used his hand to give Voldemort life, and Voldemort gave Peter 
the silver hand...

Maybe at the end of  book seven,
Harry and Voldemort confront each other.
Knowing what happened the last time their wands met, they try to disarm 
each other.
Peter is there and grabs the two wands.
He decides to kill both so he would be the most powerful wizard.
Realizing that holding the dark lord's wand in his silver hand would give 
him the power to vanquish Voldemort
He uses the killing curse, but as this happens, his silver hand disappears, 
opening his arm again and he will die unless Harry does something to save him.

Phil who likes to think up possible endings like this.


[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]