[HPforGrownups] Re: Book 7 predictions
Cindy Jenkins
CindyJ2 at cox.net
Fri May 7 16:30:01 UTC 2004
No: HPFGUIDX 97855
Jim wrote:
>The vision I get is Harry somehow giving up his
>magical ability in order to take away Voldemort's ability; the
>ultimate destiny of their magical and blood links.
Pippin replied:
>Yeah, that's what I've been saying too. And I've thought of a
>way it could happen. We know that some of Harry's magical abilities
>came from Voldemort. Suppose they all did? Suppose it's Harry, not
>Neville, who was the natural-born squib. So when Voldemort finally
>dies, Harry's powers vanish forever.
Cindy here:
Jim, I think that's a great theory, but I do hope you're wrong. I'd hate to
see Harry lose his wizarding abilities. That would be too cruel. :(
Pippin, I don't think *all* of Harry's abilities could have come from
Voldemort. He is an excellent flier, just like his father. And his
patronus is a stag, the animal his father transformed into. I'm not saying
he didn't get any abilities from Lily, but we've seen at least two that in
all likelihood came from James. I imagine if *all* of his talents came from
Voldemort, his patronus would be very, very different. I think, therefore,
that Harry was born a wizard, not a squib, although he did get additional
abilities from Tom.
Cindy
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive