Neville's mysterious absence
rach9112000
RACH911 at aol.com
Sun May 9 08:49:28 UTC 2004
No: HPFGUIDX 97948
Hi. In Philosopher's/Sorceror's Stone, Neville breaks his wrist at
the first quidditch lesson. This is very typical for Neville and is
an introduction to how Neville's character will be portrayed
throughout the series (so far), as accident prone and forgetful.
However, in chapter 9 (The Midnight Duel), Neville is found
sleeping in the corridor near the entrance to Gryffindor. He tells
Harry, Ron and Hermione that he's been out there for hours and
couldn't remember the password to get in (UK version pg 116).
Knowing Neville's character, no further thought is really needed for
this because it's a very believable situation for Neville to get
himself in.
However, firstly I think this is strange because surely someone
from Gryffindor would have seen him but obviously this depends on
exactly how many hours Neville was outside for.
But my biggest question is, what Neville was doing between the
quidditch lesson where he broke his wrist and arriving outside
Gryffindor because he can't have been in the hospital wing with
Madam Pomfrey for very long, as he tells the trio that:
"Madam Pomfrey mended it in about a minute" - UK version pg 116.
Neville can't have gone to tea because none of the Gryffindor
fifth years saw him there as none of them were expecting him back at
the dormitory that night, otherwise they would have questioned his
absence when they went to bed (UK version pg 115).
Any ideas?
Rachel
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive