Sirius Black Lives (was Janus and also Prophecy thoughts) Long

[dumbledore11214]

No: HPFGUIDX 97960

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "Susan" <teilani2002 at y...> 
wrote:
> 
> 
> I keep thinking about this as well.  Too many similarities between 
> what happened at the MoM to Sirius and the things JKR says in other 
> places. I know what she said in her interview re: killing Sirius, 
and 
> I used to be worried that he wasn't coming back, but after visiting 
> here, I really am convinced we haven't seen the last of him.  
> 
> As far as biblical similarities referred to above, wouldn't Sirius' 
> sacrifice also be the fact that he was *not* there at the MoM like 
HP 
> thought, but as soon as he found out HP thought he was there he 
went 
> there?  HP thought he was saving Sirius and Sirius thought he was 
> saving HP.
>

Oh, Susan. I missed your post, when I wrote my previous one. Sorry!
Yes, that would be and ending I will be much happier than Harry 
dying.  


Yes, I am too convinced (especially after last JKR chat) that Sirius 
will show up in one form or another. I don't know if JRK will make me 
completely happy by resurrecting Sirius in full flesh and blood, but 
it sure sounds good. :o)



> And what about the references to Janus?  Just the name (two faces) 
> equals deception, so maybe Sirius really did fake his death (with 
the 
> Order's help).  I think (now) that it's a giant hint to us readers 
> that he's still alive, because why else include this information 
> about Janus that's sooo similar to the incidents surrounding 
Sirius' 
> disappearance at the MoM?  The main thing that's really bugged me 
> about what happened there is that NO ONE knows (or rather, no one's 
> saying)exactly what the veil is, where it goes, what it does, where 
> it came from, etc., etc.  I siriusly doubt JKR's going to just 
leave 
> the veil unexplained after taking the trouble to introduce us to it.



I agree with you. I don't think that if Sirius was properly dead, JKR 
would allow him to come back, since she stated many times that in her 
world, "magic cannot bring dead people back"

For reasons discussed here ad naseum I still believe that he may not 
be properly dead. It is likely that JKR will crash my belief in the 
next book, but till there... 


Since I don't want to believe that Dumbledore is so evil that he 
planned Sirius death, I may choose to believe that Headmaster instead 
helped fake his death . Who knows, maybe dear headmaster realised 
that Sirius really needs to feel useful for the Order and he can give 
him something to do, while others believe that Sirius is dead.



> Also, I know some of you are concerned that time travel is going to 
> play a big part in the ending of the HP series, but I believe if it 
> was going to come into play to save Sirius (again) it would have 
been 
> done immediately after the trip to the MoM.  As we've seen/read in 
> hundreds of stories, a person can't just go back in time and fix 
> whatever it is without a bunch of other things changing as a 
result.  
> At the very least, it's too unpredictable what things would get 
> changed as a result. So, although I don't think time travel will 
> figure into the Sirius problem, I do think there's more than meets 
> the eye re: his *disappearance* through the veil.
> 
> "Susan"


I do think that time travel will come back to hunt us again(although 
I would prefer that it would not) , but I doubt it will have anything 
to do with Sirius.

I am more inclined to share the theory that Dumbleldore knows in 
advance what is about to happen from something time-travel related.


Alla