How dim is Harry? - his official History
pippin_999
foxmoth at qnet.com
Sat May 15 19:26:14 UTC 2004
No: HPFGUIDX 98442
Wanda:
> Hang on, though - what about other news sources? Didn't
Uncle Vernon know a Muggle's version of Sirius Black's
exploits? <
Pippin:
No. The Muggle witnesses to Black's crimes were memory
charmed. PoA ch 10. And since when has Uncle Vernon been
willing to answer Harry's questions?
Wanda:
>And at the beginning of OotP, Harry is eavesdropping on the TV
news, hoping to hear anything about Voldemort. Why wouldn't
he have gone looking through back issues of the newspapers,
to see how news of the WW had trickled down into the Muggle
world? <
Pippin:
The Dursleys never let Harry belong to the library. And his
research skills have never been very good anyway. He just
doesn't retain information the way Hermione does. When he
looks up stuff on his own, he gets distracted by people with
weird names and never remembers exactly what it was they did.
As for getting books out of the Hogwarts library, can you imagine
what Draco would have said if he'd spotted Harry with a copy of
Rise and Fall of the Dark Arts? 'Look, Pottie's reading about
*himself*. Can I have a signed copy, Pottie?'
Harry also is extremely reluctant to ask any question he thinks
will make him look stupid. There's only a few people he trusts
not to make fun of his ignorance. Don't-you -*read*-Hermione
isn't one of them. I admit that he is eventually going to have to get
over this, and I think we've seen signs of it in OOP already
Pippin
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive