Was Harry drugged?
huntergreen_3
patientx3 at aol.com
Sun May 16 10:59:55 UTC 2004
No: HPFGUIDX 98466
Luckie wrote:
>>In OotP, there is a passage where Harry is trying to write his
potions essay, but falls asleep as he's reading about scurvy-grass,
lovage and sneezewort...
[snip OotP quote]
Hot-headed and reckless... doesn't this sound like angsty!Harry?
And, for that matter, like Sirius? Who could have been making and/or
slipping Harry a potion? And why wait until the 5th year? There's no
saying how long the potion lasts, so my guess goes to Kreature, or
Umbridge.<<
HunterGreen:
There was a long thread about this passage back in March (if you're
curious), it starts with post 93021.
IMHO, while the passage seems to hint at a possible malicious use of
the grass, I think it was just Harry falling asleep and his mind was
wandering. There are plenty of non-magical reasons for Harry's mood
during OotP. The same goes for Sirius (although his mood lifting
during the time Kreacher is missing could be evidence of some sort of
poisoning). I think either of their emotions during OotP being
attributed to poisoning would detract from the story rather than add
to it, its too simplistic. Personally, I enjoyed Angry!Harry, it was
about time he got upset about everything he's subjected to, he always
seemed to recover too quickly from each end-of-book-calamity.
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive