[HPforGrownups] Re: Not so ESE:Lupin

[animal lover]

No: HPFGUIDX 98580


pippin:

Trouble is, Crookshanks doesn't react to Draco, Crabbe or 
Goyle, either. (PoA ch 5) It seems to me  he doesn't have the 
powers of a full Kneazle, but something more like Lord Thingy's 
ability to know when someone is lying. 

Pippin

animallover_11:

I just reread chapter 5 PoA and I see what you are saying about Draco and Company being "ignored" by Crookshanks. I happen to view the situation slighty different than you appear to. (that is what makes this interesting!!) 

Crookshanks is very interested in Scabbers at this time.  He is one that would be truly suspicious.  As much as Draco and Company are big jerks (well they are alittle worse than that but lets be polite!!) are they really that "evil"?  What have they done.  The act like normal rival teenagers.  Pick on the ones that you fear but they have not crossed any lines.  

I think it is safe to say that Peter not only crossed the line but also redrew the line. That is why Crookshanks has a big reaction to Scabbers and not Draco and Company.

As for the fact that Lupin says he is not that good at potions...if he was why would Snape be making his potion?  I would think that would be something he would have mastered.

Animallover_11


		
---------------------------------
Do you Yahoo!?
SBC Yahoo! - Internet access at a great low price.

[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]