Neville on the Quidditch team?

justcarol67 justcarol67 at yahoo.com
Wed May 19 04:38:42 UTC 2004


No: HPFGUIDX 98801

AmanitaMuscaria wrote: Thinking about it further, there's that great 
> catch Neville makes when Harry throws him the prophecy sphere in 
> OoTP - maybe it's keeper or seeker after all? I could never work that 
> out; he's been clumsy all the way through, then all of a sudden, with 
> a broken nose (which affects your bifocal vision) he does a great 
> catch without thinking about it.
> Hmmmm.


Carol:
Exactly. *Without thinking about it.* He's fine when he doesn't have
time to become self-conscious and think "I can't." Rather like Ron,
who's a very good keeper when he trusts his instincts and turns off
his conscious mind.

I don't think Neville will play Quidditch for Hogwarts, much less for
England, but I do think that he'll become less clumsy and forgetful
when he stops thinking of himself in those terms. Success breeds
success--unless you think about it too much and assume that you can't
repeat a good performance.

Carol, who can only type if she trusts her fingers to find the letters





More information about the HPforGrownups archive