Why did Ginevra petrify Mrs. Norris anyway?
meriaugust
meriaugust at yahoo.com
Thu May 20 03:04:00 UTC 2004
No: HPFGUIDX 98903
--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "vmonte" <vmonte at y...> wrote:
> vmonte:
>
> All this talk about Ginevra has got me thinking. Why did she
petrify
> Mrs. Norris in CoS? (I'm sure this was discussed before but I
began
> to have suicidal thoughts while using yahoo's search engine.) Did
the
> cat just happen to be at the wrong place at the wrong time? And
why
> not just leave the cat on the floor; why hang it by it's tail? Is
it
> possible that Ginny is an animagus, but doesn't yet know it? Could
> she have been walking the corridors (in a trance-like state) as a
cat
> and bumped into Mrs. Norris? Did she discover something about her
> while she was in cat form?
>
> Hanging the cat upside down seems rather personal doesn't it?
> Especially considering that Ginny usually likes animals.
>
> I do have to admit though that that cat is annoying...
>
> By the way, I don't see Harry and Hermione as an item. Harry and
> Ginny make a better match IMO.
>
> vmonte
Ginny was possessed by Diary!Tom Riddle when she did all this, her
own feelings towards animals nonwithstanding. The attack on Mrs.
Norris was surely directed at Filch the Squib, who in Tom's eyes
would probably be unworthy even to clean the mud off the floors of
Hogwarts, and I would guess that poor (ahem) Mrs. Norris was hung up
on the wall to make sure everyone noticed the message Ginny left.
And also, everyone else was at dinner in the crowded hall, so there
wasn't anyone else to attack. (And busting into the Great Hall would
have blown the basilisk's cover.) Also, as to Ginny being an
animagus unwittingly, I don't think being an animagus is something
you are born, it takes years of studying and skill to complete the
transformation. Anyway, to knuts worth.
Meri
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive