[HPforGrownups] Dumbledore's role in Sirius' death was Re: ESE!Snape (Was loads of other stuff)

[animal lover]

No: HPFGUIDX 98953



Potioncat:
Uhoh, I'm getting all the theories mixed up.  Would that be ESE!
Lupin killing Sirius or Lupin killing ESE!Sirius? (I presume it's 
Lupin you're hinting at...)

OK, I'll ask: If Sirius was a Voldy agent, why did he just sit still 
in 12 Grimmauld Place and do nothing when he had all those 
opportunities to deliver Harry to LV?

Potioncat, who, like Carol, would like some more non-shipping threads
 
animallover_11:
If Sirius was one of LV's agents than it makes sense that he would help lead him to the MoM.  He would not want to do anything obvious or he would risk being discovered. This would be similar to snap trying to kill LV, the cover would be blown and they would be of no use.
There was discussion awhile back about how Kreacher knew when to "hurt" Buckbeak so Sirius would not be around for Harry to talk to.  Up until now I did not think too much about it. But now with this thread (and the ever so clever Kneasy) I am thinking that Sirius was deliberately not around.  He was in contact with LV and made the arrangements to "trap" Harry.  Sirius was never concerned when Kreacher was gone and "thought" he was just in the attic...but maybe he knew where he was because he sent Kreacher to the Malfoys to get his instructions.  Sirius was removed form the family tree but it is possible that he removed himself not his mother.
His mother (well the portrait) just kept yelling at him about being a traitor.  We assume it is because he is on the good side but it is possibly because he is letting the good side use his house.
If it was the good side that took out Sirius this could explain why Lupin was so reserved in his reaction to the death.  DD was also very matter of fact about the death.  It is possible that the Order members figured out that Sirius, all though wrongly accused of the Potter murders, was working with LV along.
 
animallover_11

		
---------------------------------
Do you Yahoo!?
Yahoo! Domains - Claim yours for only $14.70/year

[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]