Fudge & Percy

garybec garybec at yahoo.com
Fri May 21 00:48:53 UTC 2004


No: HPFGUIDX 99013

> 
> <Becki says;
> 
> I think Arthur will become MoM and Percy will have to eat crow, and 
> he will never live it down from his brothers.
> I am also hoping that Tonks will be the new DADA.
> Besides, Percy the DADA?  He doesn't really seem the type.


moonmyyst:
> I am working on getting the canon together for it, but you can see 
in each book the progression of Percy changing sides.  SS/PS has the 
badge going to his head, CoS you find him sending secret messages 
from the burrow, caught reading a book on Diagon Alley that has to 
do with Prefects Who Seek Power.  (and what was it that LV said in 
SS/PS *there is no good and evil - only power and those too weak to 
seek it* or something to that effect).  This is as far as I have 
been able to get so far as far as specifics, but we see him going on 
to Head Boy and then his rise at the MoM.  This is where I get the 
idea of him becoming a DE.  He is young, he is trying to break out 
of what he sees as a joke of a family (argument with his dad) and is 
trying to seek his own power and is seduced into the other side.  If 
he comes back, it will be as a spy.  The other side only wants him 
in order to use him.
> 
> As for the DADA job, who has always wanted it and even when there 
were no others, was denied for it?  What is his one big 
weakness/hatred?  What is the one thing that will swing him back to 
the other side?  And who has already shown himself as a wonderful 
teacher of the subject?  Yes, I think that in some way Harry will be 
offered the job.  Not sure if it will be offered out right or as a 
teaching assistant or tutor, but either way, it will chap Snape's 
goat.
> 
> Moonmyyst (hiding behind her shelties, waiting on the poop to 
fly!!)



No poop for Moonmyyst, just some other ideas; From Becki

You give valid reasons that Percy is going after power, even though 
he is a git, he is not evil.  He has not shown any signs of being 
evil and in order to be a DE, you have to be.  Even Bellatrix says 
to Harry in OoP when he attempts an unforgivible curse that 
you "have to truly mean it" and I don't think he has the evilness. 

In regards to the next DADA, it couldn't be Harry, for one, he is 
still a student, and for a second, I am certian that Jo said that 
Harry could never be a teacher because he could never settle for 
something that boring, (don't remember the exact wording), that he 
would need something with a lot of action.  I would not rule out 
that Snape could be the next DADA.  McGonnagal did say that Snape 
only takes students into his NEWT classes with nothing less than an 
O (outstanding) on their OWLS for him to be an auror.  If he was no 
longer the Potion Master, Harry may be able to get into it and do 
well. 

Becki





More information about the HPforGrownups archive