Harry begins to act like someone I know...

[dumbledore11214]

No: HPFGUIDX 99127

> Potioncat wrote previously: Sirius said he'd never heard of Snape 
being a Death Eater and doubted 
> DD would have hired him if he had been.  On the other hand, he knew 
> Karkaroff was a DE. That's why he told them to watch out for him. 
> And, Snape never told Harry about Sirius or really even how bad 
James 
> had been.  Harry found that out himself.
> Potioncat

 

Melanie wrote:  He never told Harry about Sirius but he certainly 
said really horrible things about his father at ever point he could.  
Whether you think James is a jerk or not, which I don't really 
believe that he was, you never belittle a child about his dead 
father.  That's just not right.  
> 
> ~Melanie
> 


I don't usually have many positive things to say about Snape's 
treatment of Harry and I agree with Melanie - you don't belittle a 
child about his dead father, ever. But, when Snape was saying these 
horrible things in PoA, I felt the despair beyond the insults. I 
thought that Snape was upset by James and Lily death and did not want 
Harry to die.

I don't know if I feel like that after OoP, though.

Alla