Assyrians still exist
Liz Muir
rowen_lm at yahoo.com
Sun May 23 04:57:44 UTC 2004
No: HPFGUIDX 99154
Sea Change replied:
> Perhaps Uncle Algie is more progressive than we think. In real
life,
> smack dab in the center of California is a city called Ceres, and a
> decently large proportion of the people living there call themselves
> Assyrian. They think they've still got a homeland and are probably
> interested in the current events in Iraq. It's not much of a
stretch
> for me to suppose in the Wizarding world this feeling is much
stronger.
Sounds interesting and pertinant. It brings up a lot of questions
for me. Can I find any information about this on the net somewhere?
> It's also possible that Uncle Algie is a Great Uncle Algie, and was
> around pre-WW1. Many muslim empires had semi-autonomous regions
with
> names that we either recognize, or which were called by that name by
> our diplomats. The Mimbulus Mimbletonia Neville has could just be a
> cutting or a meristem of the original plant.
I've run into the problem of Europeans not knowning proper Middle
Eastern names before WWI as well. Got any specific instances I could
use, or do I need to do the searching? As for the plant being a
cutting, the way Neville phrases it makes it sound fairly recent, as
in over the summer. Algie brought it specifically for him (implied:
because of his aptitude for herbology). You don't usually bring
someone a gift from a trip and not give it to them for years. If it
were a cutting, Neville might have said, "My Uncle Algie gave it to
me. It's part of a plant he got on a trip to Assyria." Slightly
different meaning there.
Rowen
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive