Prank revisited. WAS: Harry begins to act like someone I know
snow15145
snow15145 at yahoo.com
Sun May 23 05:38:24 UTC 2004
No: HPFGUIDX 99156
Pippin said:
Harry agrees with Lily that James was just as offensive to her as
Snape was. Dehumanizing someone on account of sex is just
as bad as dehumanizing on account of race, IMO. James was
behaving rudely whether he used rude language or not.
Snow replies:
Yet! Lily dated James two years later, and married him and became
part of the Order against Voldemort and his followers, which Snape
was a part of. (No one, hopefully, can see Snape as being good at
that point)
Lily, as I see it, attempted to do what was right, as Harry always
does, but in the end what was it that Lily said to Snape, after
Snape's mudblood reply? OOP pg. 648- "Fine," she said coolly. "I wont
bother in future. And I'd wash your pants if I were you, Snivellus."
Wouldn't this statement from Lily be just as bad as what James did,
extremely insulting? (the tongue is mightier than the sword) Lily
seemed a bit Hermione-ish here. Like don't embarrass me Snape, can't
you see I am attempting to help you. What follows after this
statement is directed to James being as childish or as bad as Snape
is, correcting both of them with the same blow. (quite a woman)
It's almost like Harry protecting Dudley from Dementors. This boy
(Dudley) caused Harry more harm than enough and yet what did Harry do
protect him. Dudley doesn't care about Harry and yet Harry saved him.
That doesn't mean that Harry feels that Dudley is a good person.
Harry, like his mother, just can't see injustice done to anyone no
matter how much you don't like that person, no matter what they say
or do to you. But in this respect, where Harry sees his father as
being bad and Snape as the victim has me extremely puzzled given the
circumstances of what his mother said to Snape in the end, it all
comes back to why Harry would be sympathetic to Snape, for me.
There are a lot of puzzle pieces missing.
Snow-confused
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive