Are there no depths to which Siriophiles wont sink?

[potioncat]

No: HPFGUIDX 99292

Potioncat snipping part of her own
> > But what did he do in the Shrieking Shack that you found so bad?
> > 
> 
> Meri again: In the Shreiking Shack he let his petty schoolboy 
> quarrells take over. He wouldn't listen to reason from any of 
them, 
> and seemingly fully intended to throw not just Sirius, but Lupin 
as 
> well to the dementors, two perfectly innocent men whom he could 
not 
> forgive long enough to listen to hear them out.

Potioncat: 
Well, he was expecting Lupin to transform at any minute.  And I'm 
not sure I would have bought that story either...not without seeing 
Scabbers transfigure into Pettigrew.  At best, he would have had to 
take them all in for DD to question...wait a minute, he did take 
them all in for DD to question.  

But this takes us right into the post with a subject "who is Harry 
acting like..." {oops, I forgot the actual heading and I don't know 
how to go back without losing this.}  But there is a very good 
comment by Pippin about the Shreiking Shack in post # 99025.

snip
Meri
 And I would be very interested to know what you think 
> his reasoning is behind his insult of Hermione. 
> 
> Meri - who often wonders how things would have been different if 
> Snape had been made to listen.

Potioncat:
I'll address Hermione at a different time.  I need to refer to canon 
or to one of my previous posts, but at any rate, I need more time 
(and my time turner is in the shop) But I want to add, that I find 
his behavior at that time inexcusable even if he did have a reason.

How would things have been different if Snape had been made to 
listen...I wonder that as well!

Potioncat who is having fun with this and hopes you are too!