Are there no depths to which Siriophiles wont sink?

[meriaugust]

No: HPFGUIDX 99311

Meri snips out her original post about the Shreiking Shack
> Potioncat: 
> Well, he was expecting Lupin to transform at any minute.  And I'm 
> not sure I would have bought that story either...not without 
seeing 
> Scabbers transfigure into Pettigrew.  At best, he would have had 
to 
> take them all in for DD to question...wait a minute, he did take 
> them all in for DD to question.  

Meri: You make a fair point. It must be a testament to how well 
written that book is because I am always surprised when Lupin 
transforms into the werewolf after that scene, and I usually forget 
that little detail about the wolfsbane potion. (On a side note, I 
really wish JKR would get in to the specifics about lycanthropy in 
her universe.) Anyway, had he listened to Sirius and Lupin's 
protests and taken them straight up to the castle (and not 
threatened them with dementorization) then things would have, of 
course, been very different. 
 
> Potioncat who is having fun with this and hopes you are too!

Meri - having a great time, though she is ready to admit that it is 
clear that neither of us will see eye to eye on this particular 
issue...