[HPforGrownups] Are there no depths to which Siriophiles wont sink?

[Miss Melanie]

No: HPFGUIDX 99317

Sylvia wrote: I simply can't believe some of the excuses the Sirius-lovers are 
coming up with to defend their darling.  So Snape may have possibly 
recruited Regulus into the DE (evidence??). This makes Sirius cross 
and it is understandable (though not, of course, justifiable)that he 
should want to feed Severus to his werewolf friend. Oh, he did it 
just to scare him did he?  How exactly was he going to prevent Snape 
being torn limb from limb? If he really didn't anticipate the 
consequences of what he was doing, then he WAS an idiot.  If he did, 
he was prepared to let Snape die.  

Sylvia (who doesn't expect to make many friends) 

 

My reply:  You know I don't want to condone or not condone his actions that night.  But you ask me if I like Sirius?  I do, and you know why?  Because when I see Sirius in the books I see a person who sat in Azkaban thinking everyday of his life what he did wrong?  I see a guy who sat there depressed and beaten down because he lost the only true family he had, James and Lily.  

 

I see a guy who I believe truly cared for his godson.  You know you can say whatever you want about Sirius but if he's bad then my God Snape is.  I don't care who you are or what you are you have no reason to treat a child like Snape does.  None.

 

~Melanie




		
---------------------------------
Do you Yahoo!?
Friends.  Fun. Try the all-new Yahoo! Messenger

[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]