Slytherin in Sorting Hat

[Mandy]

No: HPFGUIDX 99368

> Arianna replies:
> Isn't it obvious?  It's the shield Voldemort is holding in the 
final fight at the ministry in OOP (top of p815 Am Ed).  Maybe that 
is why he is the "heir" as opposed to simply the "last descendent."  
He somehow (magically) inherited the Slytherin's shield.   Besides, 
it makes sense: racism stems from fear, the brave house has the 
sword, the self-preserving one has a shield.  


Mandy here:
The Shield could very well be the symbol of Slytherin but I find your 
explanation of why it may be just too narrow. 

Both the sword and shield have a duality to them.  They can be used 
for good and bad. Weapon and Defense. Conquest and the Stuggle for 
freedom. Used for oneself and for others.  Neither are black or white.

The sword has two purposes: one is to attack another, and one is to 
defend oneself and/or another.  While bravery could be required to 
use a sword in the defense of oneself and/or other, so could 
cowardice and fear be a motivation in using the sword to protect 
oneself, or to force another into obeying your will.

The shield can also be used selfishly or wisely for self-
preservation, but also as protection from an attack for not only 
yourself but for others who may be without a means of defense too.

Mandy