Remus is the worst

[potioncat]

No: HPFGUIDX 99415

 
> Ally:
> 
> I think Remus is worse.  When I think of Remus, I think of the 
person 
> in the South during Jim Crow who didn't believe the races were 
> unequal but stood by and watched a lynching occur.  I think of the 
> German citizens in WWII who had nothing against the Jews but 
didn't 
> speak out when a jewish neighbor was carted off to a concentration 
> camp.
> 
> 

Potioncat:
I understand what you're saying, but I disagree about Lupin.  He 
would not be in the Order if he was that type of coward.  Yes, as a 
teen he was unable to stand up to friends. As an adult he was afraid 
to tell DD about some of his past, but he faced Pettigrew and Black 
when he thought they were attacking Harry. 
Potioncat (who agrees Lupin is flawed, but who isn't?)