Progression of the books

rmmiller95 rmmiller at gci.net
Wed May 26 06:57:30 UTC 2004


No: HPFGUIDX 99467

Jospehine <J.Z.Dench at u...> wrote:
> <snip> Each book has since become not only darker, but more mature, 
> dealing with "grown up" issues. I know that JK has progressed as a 
> writer, but is she intending the books to grow with her *original* 
> fans. 
> <snip> But what would be interesting to monitor 
> would be if JK continues to write more mature topics, will she 
> lose her younger audience? I personally cannot see an average 10 
> year old now enjoying much of GOF or OOTP, nevermind understanding 
> its complexities. <snip> Will these younger readers bypass Harry 
> Potter for another author? How 'grown up' can she get before the 
> books are too adult for children, and will she make Book 6 
> inaccessible for them?
<snip>


rmmiller95:

 I have a 7 year old and she has listened to all five books and 
understands them just fine.

 She can't wait for the next one to come out.

 I read somewhere that JKR is writing as Harry is growing up so the 
syles will grow with him.

 Maybe if your grandaughter could use the book tapes she would have 
an easier time with it.

 I know that the reading is to hard for my seven soon to be eight 
year old. 

 I don't post much so sorry if it isn't done well.







More information about the HPforGrownups archive