What about the Door?

[dumbledore11214]

No: HPFGUIDX 99493

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "potioncat" <willsonkmom at m...> 
wrote:
> I started to add this to a running post about Sirius and Severus 
and 
> the prank, but it's enough different to make a new, baggage-free 
> post.
> 
> I've no doubt that Sirius was impulsive and did not intend for 
> Severus to be killed. He should have been held accountible if 
> Severus had been injured. I believe Snape feels that Black was 
> trying to kill him.  James thought that Severus was in danger. 
Lupin 
> (current WW time) thinks Severus was in danger.
> 
> Let's see, every month Remus is taken to the Shack.  The other 
three 
> go through the tunnel and join him.  He's in the shack, not the 
> tunnel, and cannot get out.  They can get into the Shack.  
> 
> Severus is tricked into going through the tunnel.  James goes after 
> him to save him from the werewolf.  Severus sees the werewolf just 
> before he's dragged away.
> 
> Isn't the werewolf on the other side of the door?  Why would 
Severus 
> have even opened the door if he could see that there was a werewolf 
> on the other side?  Didn't Lupin say he made horrible noises and 
> sounds when he was in the werewolf state?  So wouldn't Severus had 
> heard something when he got close, even if he didn't see the 
> werewolf?  Seems to me he would have seen it, heard it and gone 
back 
> to tell everyone.  What am I missing?
> 
> Potioncat


That is the problem. We are missing soo much information about that 
night.


I want to know when for example Peter started to look at Voldemort 
supporters and think about joining. We have absolutely no information 
supporting or negating the assumption that people could joing while 
in Hogwarts. Did Peter have anything to do with Prank? Could he have 
put Severus under Imperium curse? It is outlandish, I know, but also 
possible.

Alla