What about the Door?

[potioncat]

No: HPFGUIDX 99566


Carolyn: 
> If Sirius, Peter and Lupin are telling the truth about what they 
did 
> all those years ago, then DD took a fantastic, careless risk in 
> allowing it to happen..or he knew it was happening. Did no one in 
the 
> Forbidden Forest tell him about a werewolf regularly on the loose 
> accompanied by at least two other enormous animals? All those 
magical 
> centaurs, the mer-people having a midnight float on the surface of 
> the lake? The intelligent owls, and who knows what else goes squeak 
> in the night in the WW? Even the most rudimentary information 
system 
> should have informed him what was happening.
> 

Potioncat:
I snipped a great deal. Very good post and you brought up a lot of 
good questions.  I hope we haven't found a major flow in the 
writing...but given Jo's details in the rest of the series, I'll 
overlook it if we have.

It is very hard to believe that DD didn't know the marauders could 
transfigure.  Does anyone know where it is that DD speaks about it.  
Was he misleading us again?  And certainly, he knew after the prank 
that the boys knew about the tunnel and the way to disarm the tree.
Potioncat