Why did Petunia Dursley accept Harry at the beginning?
amanitamuscaria1
saraandra at saraandra.plus.com
Fri May 28 10:12:06 UTC 2004
No: HPFGUIDX 99635
--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "mariofett1187"
<Mariofett1187 at a...> wrote:
> Dumbledore explains to Harry at the end of OoTP the magic
protecting
> him at Privet Drive-but why did Petunia accept the baby on her
> doorstep, when she and Vernon wanted nothign to do with Lily's
> family?
>
AmanitaMuscaria now - I've presumed Dumbledore used some 'persuasion'
on Aunt Petunia - possibly also on Vernon? I suspect that's where the
missing day went - taken up in convincing the Dursleys to take Harry.
That's not to say they would remember anything about it, only some
sense that they _had_ to take Harry ... I suspect obliviate might
have removed the memory of the convincing, but left the compulsion? I
presume just doing an imperio on them wouldn't have worked - I get
the sense there's more to the 'ancient magic' than what could be
forced.
I also believe that's why Sirius Black had to die - we've got 2 books
left, with more deadly attacks coming. Dumbledore states that while
Harry could still call Privet Drive home, he'd enjoy the protection
Lily's blood gave him. Harry was about to call Sirius Black's house
home. I reckon it's a setup job; not ESE!Dumbledore, but scheming,
pragmatic DD.
> On a related note, is Harry vulnerable to attack by Voldemort when
he
> wanders around Little Whinging? Dumbledore said that he is
protected
> only when he is in the Dursley's house.
>
> "mariofett"
AmanitaMuscaria again - I presume, again, that Harry is vulnerable.
The Dementors (if they were Dementors), though not sent by Voldemort,
as far as we know, didn't attack the house. But why else have a watch
on Harry when he steps outside the house?
Cheers. AmanitaMuscaria
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive