New Clue - Graveyard at Hogwarts
earendil_fr
viviane at lestic.com
Sat May 29 16:26:45 UTC 2004
No: HPFGUIDX 99727
arealin wrote:
> I think that maybe the graveyard has something to do with ghosts.
> Perhaps all the ghosts who inhabit Hogwarts are buried there. We
> might find out more about ghosts and the rules of their existence.
> Anyway, it would just make sense to me if that's what the
graveyard
> was there for.
Earendil:
That's a very, very interesting idea you have here. After hearing
that piece of information, I was wondering why there would be a
graveyard at Hogwarts at all, and how it could come into play. But
the whole ghosts mystery really makes sense.
If Hogwarts' ghosts were buried there, it explains why they haunt
Hogwarts while they might have died somewhere else. Apart from
Myrtle and Binns, we have no information on where they died, but
judging from Nick's story (the book's version is edited, you can
find the full original story on JKR's new website) he's very likely
to have died somewhere else.
Also, there could be non-ghosts buried in that graveyard. So who
could possibly have been buried there? Honestly, I don't buy the
James&Lily theory. I can think of no reason why they would have been
buried at Hogwarts (unless it has some unknown obscure property). If
anyone can explain why they would have been buried *specifically* at
Hogwarts and not somewhere else, please share!
OTOH, I could picture the founders being buried there... *That*
would make sense...
Earendil, amazed to see how we all manage to speculate on tidbits of
unconfirmed information ;-)
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive