Priori Incamtatum Goof? (was Re: Lupin Loved Lily)

arealin alina at distantplace.net
Sun May 30 07:23:47 UTC 2004


No: HPFGUIDX 99773

<snip>
> Which brings me back to the order in which the ghost-figures 
appeared in the
> priori.  I guess I am just too dense to see where the goof was and 
have to
> reread GOF...again. <Grin>
> 
> Cheers,
> 
> Lee :-)

The goof was that the spells appear from the wand in the order last 
to first. So since James was killed first and Lily second, then 
Lily's ghost would appear from the wand first and James' second. But 
in the earlier editions, James comes out first and says "Your mother 
is coming." 

By the way, does anyone know how exactly this was corrected in later 
editions? What did Lily say when she appeared first?

Alina.





More information about the HPforGrownups archive