New Clue - Graveyard at Hogwarts
suehpfan
stanleys at sbcglobal.net
Mon May 31 03:26:01 UTC 2004
No: HPFGUIDX 99816
--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "pippin_999" <foxmoth at q...>
wrote:
>
> > vmonte replies:
> >
> > What if DD wanted to protect their bodies. If a piece of a
> subject's hair is needed to make polyjuice potion, what else can
> be made with the bodies of the dead. Maybe, DD is taking care
> of their graves by ensuring that they aren't desecrated. (I know
> I'm morbid.)<
>
> I think this is an excellent point, not morbid at all, except that
> black magic in general is morbid. The Hand of Glory, which
> appears in CoS, is made from the hand of a corpse. The body
> parts of magical creatures have powers after their
> deaths--dragon blood and heartstrings for example. Wizard
> graveyards probably have very powerful magical protections on
> them to keep Dark Wizards from harvesting the remains.
> Therefore the Trio could not make a casual visit as Cuaron
> would have had them do.
>
> Pippin
Hi All,
In GoF, Crouch!Moody explains he kept Moody alive in order to
question him and because he needed to use his hair for the potion
(paraphrased from GOF hardback, US pg 689). I had always thought the
person had to be alive in order for Polyjuice to work. If the hair
was from a dead person wouldn't the drinker turn into a corpse?
It is also very interesting to consider what sort of enchantments are
on WW graveyards. I think you are correct in assuming there must be
many, Pippin. In an earlier thread someone postulated that perhaps
Harry was in a graveyard near by Hogwarts in the scene in GoF. We
know from canon that the GoF graveyard is in Litte Hangleton and
Harry himself notes that "...they had obviously traveled miles--
perhaps hundreds of miles--for even the mountains surrounding the
castle were gone" GoF HB US pg 636.
I think the most interesting question of all is why Harry et all wind
up there in book 6. In the March 4th chat JKR said if she had a
chance to meet Harry she would take him to lunch and apologize to him
because she knows all of the horrible things that are going to happen
to him. I don't think Harry is through learning about the nature of
good and evil and the choices his father made in his life. If
Harry's parents are buried at Hogwarts, perhaps it is Harry who will
seek something from inside one of their caskets that he needs to
solve some other mystery.
Just pondering...
Sue(hpfan)
P.S. This also answers the ancient posts (fall maybe?) about what
rituals the WW has for "disposing" of their dead. Thank you JKR for
answering one tiny little riddle.
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive