Myrtle in the cold, cold ground...

sbursztynski greatraven at hotmail.com
Mon May 31 12:06:11 UTC 2004


No: HPFGUIDX 99826

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "meriaugust" 
<meriaugust at y...> wrote:
< Snip>
> Meri: Ooooh, interesting...You mean like the Black Cauldron 
from 
> Lloyd Alexander? That would be something else, wouldn't it? 
We don't 
> know anything about how dementors get created or where they 
come 
> from. Wandering, soulless, deathless corpses anyone? I really 
hope 
> JKR explains that particular piece of cannon as well.

Sue: As good an idea as any. I always did wonder who or what 
the Dementors were, though, strictly speaking, they seem to 
have minds, however primitive, which the "reborn" of the 
Cauldron don't. But it sure makes more sense than the notion of 
Dementor families, baby dementors, etc. ;-)  
>  
> > --Eric, who thinks that if he were a ghost he'd be known as
> > Never-Gets-Out-Of-The-Library Eric.  (Hey, it beats Nearly-
> Headless Nick!)
> 
> Meri - who were she a ghost may very well be haunting the 
library 
> with you (Merely Reading Meri? Doesn't have the same ring to 
is as 
> Sir Properly Decapitated Podmore, though does it?)


Sue : Chuckle! Don't forget, though, that as a ghost you wouldn't 
be able to touch the books! Unless they were particularly smelly 
books? (g. See COS). 





More information about the HPforGrownups archive