The intended murder of Pettigrew and moral corruption (Was; Vengeance on Sna

[dumbledore11214]

No: HPFGUIDX 117002


> Carol adds:
> And like it or not, Voldemort *must* acquire a body in order for 
Harry
> to defeat him and fulfill the Prophecy.


Alla:


I don't , Carol :o) I don't like it at all. I would like for Harry 
to be able to worry about other things than the fate of the whole WW.

I also have quite a few reservations such as that Dumbledore could 
have misinterpreted the prophecy.



Carol.
> But I agree with barmaid; Voldemort would have found a way to come
> back, perhaps through Barty Jr. He would not have remained a 
spirit in
> the wilderness for long. And now that he has one, he can be
> annihilated forever in Book 7.
>

Alla:

Well, yes, of course. Voldemort would have found a way to come back, 
most likely. But the whole point of speculation  "what would happen 
if Sirius and Remus killed Peter" was (at least IMO) to see how the 
story would turn out for the better for those three (Sirius, Remus 
and Harry), not for Dumbledore plans to get rid of Voldemort. :)