Good moral core (Re: Dirty Harry/Clean Harry)

[dumbledore11214]

No: HPFGUIDX 117112


> Neri:
> I don't think Harry ever decided "to be good" (though perhaps 
Hermione
> did ;-) ). 

Alla: Heee!

Neri:
 He just had a series of choices in his life, as we all
> have, and in most of them, or at least in those that mattered the
> most, he tried to do things right.

Alla:

Agreed.


Neri:
 snip.

 If
> you accept that he has free will, you must be satisfied 
with "because
> after considering the options (or not) he decided that option A was
> better than option B".



Alla:

Sorry for continuing bugging, but since I am often in agreement with 
95% of what you write, I want to figure out whether I am in 
disagreement this time or wheI am still confused.:o)

I agree with you about free will, I guess I am just thinking that 
free will has to come from somewhere too, initially at least.

OK, let me try to rephrase my question again - how does Harry KNOW 
which decisions are right? What helps him: higher power? generation 
memory? What?