Good moral core (Re: Dirty Harry/Clean Harry)

[dumbledore11214]

No: HPFGUIDX 117161


> Neri:
> Sure it comes from somewhere initially. There is nature and there 
is 
> nurture. A child is born with certain genes and interacts with his 
> environment. But then at some point free will appears. Once it did, 
> the chain of cause and effect sort of breaks down. It must be, or 
the 
> choices of the child would be uniquely determined by his nature and 
> nurture, and then it's not free will.


Alla:


Do you feel that free will is given to us by G-d? If I understood 
Geoff's position correctly, that was his POV.

That I understand perfectly ( not sure if I agree or not, but at 
least understand).


I think I at least agree with you that free will is not with us from 
birth.

 I think I am in the most agreement with Susan - that Harry does it 
because it "feels right", but who gave him this "moral compass"?