Family ties.
potioncat
willsonkmom at msn.com
Thu Nov 4 21:09:47 UTC 2004
No: HPFGUIDX 117243
> Kneasy:
> But there's a bit you missed out:
> "Voldemort put a bit of himself in me?" Harry said, thunderstruck.
> "It certainly seems so."
> That, combined with listing the qualities prized by Slytherin with
no
> indication that these weren't also passed across at the same time.
> Powers are different. There's only one we know of so far
(Parseltongue)
> though DD does say that powers (plural) were transferred.
>
> Now others may disagree, but I reckon "...a bit of Voldemort.."
is not
> the same thing as "Voldemort's powers." I think the former phrase
> was used very deliberately.
>
> Powers per se are not a problem, they can be used without hazard
> to the recipient (so long as he can control them). But a bit of
Voldy
> is a different cauldron of toads; it implies much more than just
being
> able to cast an unusual spell or two. IMO it's what allows the
link,
> often at considerable distances, much further than shown between
any
> other pair, between Harry and Voldy. The Dark Mark calls his
disciples;
> but it doesn't affect their minds, only their arms.
> Voldy can stroll round Harry's mind because he has a foothold
there
> already.
> Part of Harry's mind *is* part of Voldy.
Potioncat:
Oh, I agree there's a bit of LV in Harry,and I didn't mean it was
only the Parseltongue. I think Snape has been looking for something
of LV in Potter all along. And there will likely be more
bits showing up in books 6 & 7.(Wasn't there a thread about
that...of course, let's face it, there's been a thread about
everything.)
But I think the resourcefulness, disregard for rules and whatever
the other was (snipped too well) are from James. Discribes him
perfectly.
>
>
> >
>
> Kneasy:
> Pureblood is different to Muggle born is different to mudblood.
> Sometimes labels are useful, sometimes they restrict.
> Two or three generations back and a dalliance with a Muggle milkman
> ruins a pureblood pedigree. But that wouldn't make the later
descendents
> Muggleborn. Far enough back and it'd be difficult to call them
mudblood.
> Harry isn't Muggleborn - but he was thought suitable for
Slytherin, even
> though Lily came from Muggles (we think).
>
> No; I'm convinced that whatever Snape's motivation is for swapping
> sides (and most agree that there must be a strong one) I reckon
it's
> *personal*, something to do with family. It's not such a giant
leap to
> wonder if his family had interesting connections.
Potioncat:
We agree here. There must be some surprising connection. And I
wouldn't be surprised to discover that Snape was Halfblood like
Harry. He's a prince of a man too, everyone says so....
(No, I'm not serious about the last part.)
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive