Inside Harry's mind
Barry Arrowsmith
arrowsmithbt at btconnect.com
Wed Nov 10 14:20:06 UTC 2004
No: HPFGUIDX 117541
A few quotes to start with:
"...and Slytherin will help you on the way to greatness, no doubt about
that..." ( the Sorting Hat, PS/SS)
"Voldemort put a bit of himself in me?" (Harry, CoS)
"...there's something funny about the Potter kid, we all know that."
(Moody, OoP)
" Quite astonishing, the way you continue to wriggle out of very tight
holes....*snakelike*, in fact" (authors emphasis. Malfoy OoP)
It's long been accepted that there's a Voldy fragment in Harry, though
the details of just what magic caused it has been the subject of much
debate. (Though if what happened was known to us, JKR said that there
would be no point in writing books 6 & 7. Does that sound as if it was
a simple bouncing AK? Not to me.) Less time has been spent discussing
*how much* of Harry is Voldy.
The first quote is interesting in that it can have variant meanings;
is it Slytherin House the Sorting Hat is referring to, or old Salazar
himself? (Possession theory would allow the latter.) Secondly, the
wording: not *could* help - but *will* help. Since the Hat looks at
future potential as well as current characteristics, just what
fraction of Harry was it measuring? The Potter or Voldy bit? Did it
foresee the former succumbing to the latter perhaps?
There's a spectrum of possibilities, at one end there being just a
small isolated fragment in there, through to a major chunk - even a
possibility that Harry *of himself* is not magical at all, all his
magical ability being derived from the transplant. Choose for yourself
where in the range of possibilities you think it falls.
For myself, I'd go lower middle; not insignificant, but not
overwhelming - yet. But I also think that something very important but
so far largely unappreciated happened in the graveyard.
(Oh, a small digression to repeat a fun possibility I mentioned last
year - we're led to believe that Snape hates and fears Voldy. What if
his reaction to Harry is because as an ex-DE and part-time Legilimens
he sees Voldy inside Harry? Snape sees the potential for an ESE!Harry,
a demi-clone of Snape's bitterest enemy. A thoroughly entertaining
turning of the tables.)
Since GH Harry has had 'Lily's Protection', an anti-Voldy shield that
protected not against spells cast with evil intentions, but against
Voldy the individual. Quirrell!Mort could cast spells, but he couldn't
touch. After GoF Voldy demonstrates that now he *can* touch - while
posturing to his fawning DEs he admits that Harry had been given
protection that meant "...I could not touch the boy. [...] but no
matter, I can touch him now." And does so.
But there is not just a Voldy exterior to Harry, there's something
interior too. That piece inside him. For whatever reason it wasn't
destroyed or expelled at GH; it sat there. Occasionally it would
flare up, the scar would hurt and Harry would know Voldy was up to
something specifically Potter orientated. There were also dreams when
Voldy was considering doing something nasty to him. But no link, not
like there was in OoP where for nearly a year his scar played up more
or less continuously, thoughts and ideas passed to and fro and Harry's
behaviour showed drastic changes.
No longer the well-meaning, slightly dim, ready to jump to the wrong
conclusion for the right reasons Harry, but a progression to a stroppy,
irritable, bad-tempered, disobedient and thoroughly awkward customer
ready to be misled by outside influences - even after he'd been warned
of the possibility. Why the change? The events in the graveyard, of
course. Any restraint the Lily Protection had on the Voldy!Fragment has
now gone and it's effect is beginning to show. DD is worried about it
too - "But in essence divided?" A question, note; not a statement.
After Harry has his Arthur dream DD is worried that Harry is quite
literally not himself.
Previously it was only the Sorting Hat, DD and to a lesser extent
Harry who may have wondered. Now others are too. Moody, the implacable
Auror trained to sniff out Dark Magic thinks there's something funny
going on. And Lucius; now why would he consider Harry snakelike? Just
what does he know or suspect, and where is he getting his information
from? Hmm.
During KR's web-cast back in March there were the following Q&As:-
Q: 'Are Harry's powers going to get any greater?'
A: Yes, he's really progressing as a wizard now (which is lucky,
because I know what's in store for him).
Q: 'Regarding Harry's subconscious feelings, how has it changed from
book 1 to book 5?'
A: 'Well he's obviously been through a lot since book 1 and book 5 was
the book where he cracked up a little. In book 6, the WW is really at
war again and he has to master his own feelings to make himself
useful.'
Good oh! Could be plenty of action, Harry in for a hard time of it,
maybe a Weasley corpse or two littering the scenery. Splendid!
But that second one - I have suggested previously that Harry tries to
avoid his 'fate' by refusing to co-operate with DD any more after the
death of Sirius. Could that be what is meant by 'mastering his
feelings'?
Or are there a totally alien set of feelings that have to be mastered?
Could be fun.
Kneasy
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive