Re: JKRs giant mistake? (who says the name)
pippin_999
foxmoth at qnet.com
Fri Nov 12 02:19:05 UTC 2004
No: HPFGUIDX 117665
Neri , some time ago:
> Now, I always had the strong suspicion that Crouch!Moody
using the V- word here is simply an editing mistake.
<massive snippage>
> No, they don't. All three of them use "Voldemort's".
>
> Pettigrew: "If Voldemort's supporters were after me"
>
> Crouch Sr: "you were caught passing information to Lord
Voldemort's supporters".
>
> Crouch Jr: ""Voldemort's back, Harry?"
>
> Now, I'm sure you can build a very interesting theory on this
amazing coincidence, but I have a horrible suspicion that the
explanation is rather mundane: JKR or one of her editors run a
computerized search over all occurrences of the word
"Voldemort" in the manuscripts, when editing them, to make
sure this word is not spoken by any character who shouldn't
speak it. Unfortunately they have the option "find whole words
only" checked, and so they miss the "Voldemort's" cases.
>
Pippin:
Um, I just did a simple check with the most commonly used
word-processing program, and "find whole words only" locates
"Voldemort's" just fine.
Pippin
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive