[HPforGrownups] Apparition lessons (was Re: Draco's POV?)

[manawydan]

No: HPFGUIDX 117701

 Steve wrote:
>Next, we have never seen the Room provide anything /active/ like a
>portkey. It provided space, books, bookshelves, pillows/cushions, and
>various magical instruments (Foe Detectors/secrecy sensors). I suspect
>the magical instruments are only valid and active within the confines
>of the Room. That is on the assumption that the magical devices were
>created by the Room itself. Harry says that he suspects that the Foe
>Glass was the Glass that once belonged to Mad Eye Moody. If that is
>true then the Room summoned it from somewhere in the castle; it didn't
>create it. That instrument would work inside or outside the Room,
>because it wasn't created by the Room.
{snippage}
>So, getting into The Room from outside Hogwarts would be difficult,
>and relying on any object created by The Room, outside The Room, would
>not be reliable or advisable.

I think I'm right that Dobby mentions Filch using the room to replenish his
cleaning supplies if he ran out unexpectedly. Therefore it must be able to
create things that can be taken outside and still exist.

There's no canon support as to whether Argus uses magical cleaning materials
(Mrs Skower's for example) but it's probably because why would there be any
other sort in the WW?

So in that small respect the RoR must be able to generate magical "stuff".

I'd like to think, also, that Dumbledore, having utilised one of the chamber
pots, would have taken it to the nearest toilet to empty it without it, um,
dissolving as he walked down the corridor...

cheers

Ffred

O Benryn wleth hyd Luch Reon
Cymru yn unfryd gerhyd Wrion
Gwret dy Cymry yghymeiri