Why has DD never suggested Snape thank Harry? (Was: Why has DD never suggest

[dumbledore11214]

No: HPFGUIDX 117738


> Potioncat:
> McGonagall "assumed" that Harry had tricked Draco into wandering 
> around the castle at night by telling a wild story about a dragon.
> 
> McGonagall jumped all over Harry and the Weasley twin (Fred or 
> George) for "attacking" Draco after he really insulted their 
mothers 
> at the Quidditch game.  
> 
> Snape isn't the only one who takes Draco's side but no one ever 
> complains about Minnie. 
> 


Alla:

Oy, I expected better from you. :o) McGonagall taking Draco's side 
is called being "fair" in my book. Why would I complain about that?
Now, the exact analogy for Snape's behaviour would be.... that is 
right him taking Harry's side. When would we see that?



> Potioncat:
> Let's face it.  Even if Gryffindor had had 10 points by that time, 
> taking them was not going to matter.  So what?
> 
> So either Snape sees what looks like Harry picking on Malfoy and 
> takes points in what would be fair punishment(but meaningless) or 
he 
> saw it was Malfoy's fault and administers unfair (but meaningless) 
> punishment.


Alla:

But that is the whole point, right? If Snape saw that it was 
malfoy's fault - then there was absolutely NO NEED to do anything. 
he could at least IGNORE the accident and show that he has some 
humanity left in him. 

Potioncat: 
> Oh, Alla, Snape lives to make you happy and you slap him!
> Oh, wait, he was a friend of Bella's....I'd better not ask. ;-)

Alla:

LOLOL! (Humming Happy Birthday)