Kreacher's bandages

TheMuffinMan0311 at comcast.net TheMuffinMan0311 at comcast.net
Sat Nov 13 16:22:21 UTC 2004


No: HPFGUIDX 117806


 
> Carol earlier: 
> "Has anyone noticed that Kreacher's hands are bandaged as if he 
> has just ironed them when Harry tries to contact Sirius Black using 
> Umbridge's fireplace (OoP Am. ed. 740)? Has he ironed them in advance 
> because he's in the process of betraying his master or because he has 
> just injured Buckbeak or . . . ? 


What you're all missing is what Dumbledore said at the end of the 
book! (funny how much you guys forget) Kreacher was taking orders 
from the Malfoys who are related to the Blacks, so he wasn't 
disobeying orders. He was told to get out, he went to the Malfoys, 
the Malfoys gave him an order, he followed without needing to punish 
himself because he was taking orders from a family member! So he 
definitely got those bandages from somewhere other than beating 
himself...\

TheMuffinMan,
"Its Always Darkest Just Before It Gets Pitch Black..."








More information about the HPforGrownups archive