Apparition lessons / 'can't apparate at Hogwarts'

Juli jlnbtr at yahoo.com
Sun Nov 14 03:28:19 UTC 2004


No: HPFGUIDX 117842


--- TheMuffinMan0311 at comcast.net wrote:
(EDITED)
> I never said that magic wasn't allowed, magic is
> allowed there, but think of the dangers of having 
> it able to be apparated to? Do you know how easy 
> it would be to get into Hogwarts if you could 
> apparate at Hogsmeade then take a 5 minute walk 
> to the castle? Sorry, but I believe there's no way 
> an ancient barrier like the one around Hogwarts would
> ever be limited to Hogsmeade so the villagers could 
> have "fun". (This is not an angry tone, just a "I 
> don't agree" tone.)


Don't worry, I didn't take it as an angry tone. But
I'm sticking to my idea, You should be able to
Apparate at Hogsmeade. Besides, I don't think the
reason why LV never went to Hogwarts during VWI is
that he was (and is) scared of Dumbledore. Somewhere
it says that Hogwarts was one of the few safe places.
Why? because DD was there to protect his students and
his faculty. I didn't mean that Apparition is "fun", I
just think it's the best way to get there. 

Juli











More information about the HPforGrownups archive