Sirius's Future

[pippin_999]

No: HPFGUIDX 117864


--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, annegirl11 at j... wrote:
> Katya said:
> [Some very interesting stuff that I'm snipping b/c I don't have 
any
> specific comments on it]
> 
> ITA. Have you depressing naysayers never watched tv? No 
body, no death. At least, no certain death. And portals never do 
what you think they do. The whole thing was wayyy too dodgy to 
be a straight-out death.
> 

Pippin
Oh, JKR, she knows her fans, yes she does. She dares us to 
ask her whether Sirius is really dead, and all the time she's 
laughing in her sleeve at us, because the question we *should* 
be asking is who killed him.

I think we'll see Sirius again as a memory, but he won't be 
coming back from the portal, because if he did, he'd have to tell 
Harry who killed him. (Harry! Revenge!) As Harry is far more 
decisive than Hamlet, it wouldn't be much of a story

I think canon will show that we *all* die with our lives unfinished, 
for they continue elsewhere. Not my personal belief, but that 
seems to be where canon is tending.
.
Pippin