[HPforGrownups] Trelawney - real seer or not? (was Re: DU treatment of Trelawney)

[Juli]

No: HPFGUIDX 117896


--- charme <dontask2much at yahoo.com> wrote:
> 
> Charme:
> Funny, but perhaps foreshadowing by JKR.  If the
> theorists who proclaim that a part of TR is in 
> Harry as a result of LV trying to kill him at GH, 
> they could have more support should we discover 
> that TR was born in the middle of winter. :)


I believe there's some of LV in Harry, but why would
it change his birthday? I mean, he was born on July,
and LV tried to kill him over a year later in
October, so if anything I would say he could have been
"born" on October (the middle of autumn), maybe this
was some sort of re-born, since that night changed his
entire life. Let's say LV was born on January, when he
tranferred some of his powers to Harry (like
parseltongue), how could he transfer his birth, this
would make Harry 70+.

Juli