Did DD lie about the Prophecy?

[pippin_999]

No: HPFGUIDX 117931



> > Kneasy wrote:
> > > It was a not-so  subtle warning. Because the Prophecy 
wasn't about  Peter, it was about Sirius.<<<

Dungrollin:
> > Have I missed it, or has anyone come up with a way of 
making  the '... chained these twelve years.  Tonight, before 
midnight, the  servant will break free ...' fit with Sirius, who 
escaped from  Azkaban 10 months previously?  

Kneasy:
> Fits better than with Peter, who was never chained at all.
 He could have left any time he wanted to.<

Pippin:
Fits Lupin even better, since we have no idea where he was for 
twelve years. We do know  he broke free from the chain holding 
him to Peter, and set out before midnight. Of course, he had to 
stop by the next day and pick up his belongings, including the 
grindylow cage. That would hold a rat, especially if you put an 
Unbreakable Charm on it.

Pippin
who will never finish writing the ESE!Lupin treatise if she doesn't 
stop finding more clues