The Riddles' Murders (WAS: The only one he ever feared?
ginnysthe1
ginnysthe1 at yahoo.com
Tue Nov 16 01:01:25 UTC 2004
No: HPFGUIDX 117946
Kim asked:
>And I'll toss out this last question: who do you think taught young
Tom Riddle how to perform an Avada Kedavra?<
JP replied:
>I think that Tom had "theoretically" known how to use the AK Curse,
you know, knowing the incantation and everything... <snip> ... the
user must mean it... savor the pleasure of hurting or killing someone
in order to use it properly. And I think that Tom Jr did: he meant
to kill his family, and following logically the attitude of the
present day Voldy, had the pleasure of doing so.>
Kim replies:
I see what you're saying, but I was wondering specifically *who*
taught young Tom the Unforgiveable Curses? Not that I really have
any idea myself. Learning AKs, etc. would seem to require more than
looking in a book, even for a gifted student. And at Hogwarts at
least, these curses are pretty much forbidden, aren't they, despite
the fact that Moody!Crouch taught them in GoF? So maybe learning
Unforgiveables was part of an "underground movement" among the bad
students (bad, as in mean and nasty), similar to the way "the
Marauders" had to learn how to become animagi without the knowledge
of their professors. But studying Unforgiveable Curses on one's own
would have to be kept even more hushed up than studying animagus
transfigurations, because of the shear illegality of Unforgiveables.
Maybe TR and friends found outside help in their studies from
unsavory types, whoever they may have been. Something to ponder
anyway!
Cheers, Kim
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive