DD admits he's an animagus
ginnysthe1
ginnysthe1 at yahoo.com
Wed Nov 17 02:07:36 UTC 2004
No: HPFGUIDX 118050
John wrote:
> He [Dumbledore] says "I have absolutely no intention of being sent
to Azkaban. I could break out of course-- but what a waste of time,
and frankly, I can think of a whole host of things I would rather be
doing".<
Juli replied:
>Maybe he is both an animagus and methamorphmagus, I mean he is DD,
he's the man, the puppet-master of the WW, the most powerful wizard,
so sure he could also be an unregistered animagus, just like the
Marauders, but there's a third option: he is neither, he's just so
powerful he can escape the Dementors (wait, was this scene before or
after the 5 DEs escaped and the dementors quitted?) without using a
wand. But, if it was after the dementors left Azkaban, how easy would
it be for him to just leave.<
Kim now:
I really went for John's theory of animagus ability because I've been
pushing for it too (like Patrick(?), et al.) No doubt DD would be
able to do many other things to aid his escape from Azkaban, but DD
having animagus ability is just so obvious and beautiful an idea to
me (and such an unexamined but likely aspect of DD's talent, so IMO
JKR has been keeping it a secret up til now for some reason).
However, IIRC, the only time the animagus register was mentioned was
when Hermione looked at it and didn't find the Marauders on it
(though she did find McGonagall). But she said she'd looked at the
register only for the last 100 years, didn't she? That may mean that
DD is actually on the animagus register, but since he's 150 years
old, he may be on the register from the *previous* century, and
Hermione didn't look at that one!
Regards, Kim
More information about the HPforGrownups
archive