The Second Prophecy

[dumbledore11214]

No: HPFGUIDX 118053


> Neri:

snip.
 
> Of course, the solution to this small problem is obvious: There 
must 
> be TWO people named Sirius in the HP saga, and JKR was referring 
to 
> the other Sirius in this quote.
> 
> Generally speaking, it would be very efficient to assume that 
there 
> are two characters answering to each name in the WW, and one of 
them 
> is on the good side while the other is on the dark side. This 
would 
> enable JKR to say anything to us without (heaven forbid!) lying. 
> 


Alla:

Yes, yes, yes. This IS the best solution to many of our discussions. 
Since I am one of those dull list members,who believes that Love and 
ability to love is indeed a great redeeming quality of 
the "potterverse" characters, I don't believe that THAT Sirius is 
ESE!, so let his double be ESE!

Now, who else? Oh, yes. Lupin, of course. Pippin had been suggesting 
THAT for ages :o)

Whom else do we have? Oh, Dumbledore. Of course there are two of 
them. One of them is wise and old wisard, who is tries his best to 
win this war, loves Harry, but makes mistakes, because he loves too 
much.

Another is a Puppetmaster!Dumbledore, who is ruthless manipulator 
and knows no compassion or pity whatsoever.

Olivier already described two Harrys.

Neri, thank you for the laugh.