The Second Prophecy plus a correction

[Juli]

No: HPFGUIDX 118095


> chrusotoxos wrote:
> I really can't believe that someone out there is
> distrusting Sirius...I mean, I'm not in love with 
> him, dead or not. I think he's handsome, brilliant 
> and ironical, but godamn arrogant and immature. 
> But he's on the good side. Was. 

I agree with you Chrusotoxos, Sirius was a great guy,
a bit inmature, but nice, he deeply cared for Harry
and the Trio, and for the rest of the order, he acted
like a child because in his mind he's still 22, he
spent 12 years in Azkaban which didn't help him grow
as a person, all he remembers before Azkaban are his
friends, so he wants to hold on to them as long as
possible. And yes, he is handsome and sexy, even JKR
admits it. I read in an other post a suggestion about
him being gay, that's just not right, he's very manly,
and I bet that if he hadn't spent 12 years in jail, he
would be married by now and with a bunch of kids (Hmm,
Harry would have 'cousins'). I don't think Lupin is
gay either, he's just an unlucky guy who because his
werewolf condition has never found his significant
other.

> As for Lupin killing him, are you mad? Dumbledore 
> didn't want him dead in the first place, he 'believes 
> in second chances', he surely thought, as he did for 
> Snape, that the past can be fought and beaten.

But Lupin hasn't even used his first chance, because I
don't think not telling DD about the marauders becoming 
animagus is a huge mistake, nobody got hurt. So what's 
his first chance? Becoming a werewolf? Nope, it's not 
like he did it on purpose. Sirius may have doubted about 
him 14 years ago, but it was only for a brief period of 
time. Since he's the only one left from the marauders, 
he may start looking more after Harry.

> Dumbledore trusted Sirius. And if we can't trust
> Dumbledore, we can't trust anyone...
> Don't you agree?

Hermione is a bright girl, but remember she said this
about Snape? And still Harry doesn't trust him, but I
do, as I trust Sirius and Harry did.

Juli