Unfortunate!Peter

[Juli]

No: HPFGUIDX 118241


Kneasy:
<big snippage> 
> 2. Scabbers vanishes into the sewers. Right. Then
what? Where does he go? Who does he see? Want a
suggestion? OK - Dumbledore. Neither the  DEs nor the
MoM people believe he's alive. Who's left? DD. It's
maybe my memory, but unlike just about all the adults
in the books I  can't remember DD ever saying or
hinting or commenting in PoA that he believed Peter
was dead. If I'm wrong I'm sure someone will correct
me.

Juli:
So, DD knew Peter was alive and still he let Sirius
spend 12 years in Azkaban? I don't think DD could be
that cruel. If he knew Peter was alive wouldn't he ask
some questions? He may have thought Sirius was the SK
but still I would have some questions, like why would
an inocent man spend 12 years as a rat? He may not
have mentioned it but he must have thought he was
dead.

>At the Shrieking Shack it took two wizards wielding 
two wands simultaneously to switch him back to human
form and I begin to suspect that Peter has been
spelled. He might not even be in animagus form at all,
he could have been transfigured. And who's the
Transfiguration Supremo? DD. 

But why would DD transform Peter into a rat? It makes
no sense (at least to me), and if he did, in every
book and television show I've ever seen about magic
only the person who cast the spell could undo it, Yeah
I know JKR can change the rules, but still, Remus did
say he was going to force Peter to transform.

> Another oddity; when Scabbers runs away (when Ron
thinks Crookshanks has eaten him), where does he hide?
Hagrid's Hut. 

I think it's obvious, Hagrid cares for animals, so one
more would make no difference, besides Hagrid seems to
know some things about what's going on outside
Hogwarts so it would be a good place to hear any news
(like LV was back).

>"..nobody went bad 'cept they was Slytherin" 

Hagrid was just making a statment, and it's true most
of the Dark Wizards belong to Slytherin, one more one
less doesn't make a whole difference.

> I think Peter works for DD - and probably has for a
long time.

Then WHY would DD want LV to return? The smart choice
would be to let Harry grow up until he's prepared to
face and vanquish LV for good. It's just my opinion,
but who knows you may be right, but still this would
mean than DD wanted LV back. And ESE!DD theory doesn't
seem to be at possible.

Juli, thinking when or if we'll ever find out if all
we think is true or completly false.