[HPforGrownups]Re: Foreshadowing?

[khinterberg]

No: HPFGUIDX 118551


--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, Juli <jlnbtr at y...> wrote:
> 
> Kelly wrote:
> <SNIP>
> > My guess is that the foreshadowings could be when
> > Sirius tells Harry 
> > that those we love never really leave us 
> 
> Juli:
> I would like to believe that very much, because I felt
> really sad after Sirius crossed the veil, maybe
> somewhere in book seven we'll see Harry with Lily,
> James, Sirius and the rest of his family (without thw
> Dursleys of course), I don't mean that Harry will die,
> just hang with them, just like he did with the mirror
> of Erised and with the Priori Incantem in the duel
> with Voldemort. I hope this time they have more time
> to talk, I believe Harry does need this and probably
> will need them even more as the final battle
> aproaches, he'll need all the suport he can get, and
> The Weasleys, the Trio and DD may not be enough.
> 
> If I remember correctly there was a greveyard scene at
> the PoA movie, which wasn't in the book, this could be
> a foreshadowing of book 4 (LV rising), or something
> else in bool 6 or 7, maybe Sirius' funeral.
> 
> Juli
> 
khinterberg:
I think that Sirius's saying that the ones we love never really leave
us isn't foreshadowing so much as a statement of pure truth.  Because
in the muggle world and wizarding world alike. One part that jumped
out at me as far as foreshadowing goes was Dumbledore's statement that
Dementors will not distinguish their target from the one who gets in
their path, because this was not mentioned in the book at all.  Also,
Lupin's talk about how much Lily was there for him, also not alluded
to whatsoever in the book.  As far as his relatioship with Lily,
Cuarón said in that same interview that he didn't put anything in
there that directly contradicted Jo's current and future books, so I
believe we have to take this statement as being close to the truth at
least.

khinterberg