Guerilla ? (Re: bullies? twins, padfoot and prongs)

[dumbledore11214]

No: HPFGUIDX 118678


> Potioncat:
> But my point is, 35 year old Sirius does not think Snape was a 
DE.  So I don't think 15 year old Sirius thought so either. What 
ever bad blood there was between these boys does not excuse the 
incident.  And I would say so even if it had been Snape who attacked 
James. 

Alla:

Yes, I know - Sirius did not know that Snape was a DE, Sirius knew 
perfectly well that Snape was into Dark Arts though.
The bad blood between them does not have to be based on the fact 
that Snape was a DE, he may as well not have been recruited yet in 
school.

Dark Arts and what they are based on is what seems to be divider, as 
I see it.

And OF COURSE it does not excuse the incident, NOTHING does.

Potioncat: 
> Given how strongly the differing sides on the list feel about this 
> incident, the threads that come up after HBP should be real 
doozies!

Alla:

LOL!