Choosing sides

[arrowsmithbt]

No: HPFGUIDX 118816


--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "cubfanbudwoman" <susiequsie23 at s...> 
wrote:
> Kneasy knows that I'm one who has disagreed with him in the past 
> about choice, and I'm sure I do still see *more* of an element of 
> choice within those limited choices than he sees, perhaps because I 
> don't believe as much in Puppetmaster!DD [I see more of a 
> GrandPlanner!DD than fully Puppetmaster!DD, if that distinction makes 
> sense].  Anyway, I find that I do agree with lots that's been said 
> here in spite of a somewhat different outlook on DD and choice up to 
> this point.  
>
> enormous snip> 
> 
> I like the conclusion of this post very much.  Whether we think 
> Harry's had some true choice or that it's mostly been foisted upon 
> him by DD [or chance], at least at this point it reallly *does* 
> appear that choice will be more *fully* choice from here on in.  
> Let's hope so!!
> 
> Siriusly Snapey Susan, who loves the image of Snape snorting over how 
> easy it was to jerk Potter's chain.  Easy to picture.


Good grief! Put out more flags!
SSS has given the nod to a bit of Kneasy sneaky thinking.
Well, it's obviously a case of great minds thinking alike.

Mind you I'm a bit worried about it, I'm seriously going to have to
increase the unacceptability quotient in my next few posts; can't
have everyone agreeing with me, t'ain't natural.

Yeah, it's a nice picture, Snape chortling into his porringer of gruel,
reminiscing  on winding young Potter up. I  did start a TBAY type
piece based on Snape's diary. Must get around to finishing it one
of these days. It is, of course, totally unacceptable to canon purists.
But I like it.

Kneasy