bullies? twins, padfoot and prongs

ginnysthe1 ginnysthe1 at yahoo.com
Tue Nov 30 00:25:31 UTC 2004


No: HPFGUIDX 118844


--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "justcarol67" 
<justcarol67 at y...> wrote:
> 
>  Carol earlier (quoted by Kim)
> > "...all speculating at this point. I think that Sirius, for 
example, 
> > associated Severus with what he hated about his own home and 
family,
> > which (for me) explains his vindictiveness. He may even have
> [rejected*] that hatred of the Dark Arts onto James as an 
explanation
> of why he disliked Severus. But James seems to be entertaining 
himself
> (and Sirius) by bullying Severus in the Pensieve scene. He dislikes
> him, certainly, but he doesn't seem to share Sirius's virulent 
hatred."> 
> 
> Carol again:
> *Actually I said "projected," not "rejected." I went up thread to
> check. Don't know how the quote could have been altered if it was
> copied and pasted, or left in the original snipped message, but it
> definitely has been altered.
> 
> Carol, who was going to correct herself but discovered that the 
error
> wasn't her own

--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "justcarol67" 
<justcarol67 at y...> wrote:
> 
>  Carol earlier (quoted by Kim)
> > "...all speculating at this point. I think that Sirius, for 
example, 
> > associated Severus with what he hated about his own home and 
family,
> > which (for me) explains his vindictiveness. He may even have
> [rejected*] that hatred of the Dark Arts onto James as an 
explanation
> of why he disliked Severus. But James seems to be entertaining 
himself
> (and Sirius) by bullying Severus in the Pensieve scene. He dislikes
> him, certainly, but he doesn't seem to share Sirius's virulent 
hatred."> 
> 
> Carol again:
> *Actually I said "projected," not "rejected." I went up thread to
> check. Don't know how the quote could have been altered if it was
> copied and pasted, or left in the original snipped message, but it
> definitely has been altered.
> 
> Carol, who was going to correct herself but discovered that the 
error
> wasn't her own

Kim now, to Carol and other posters:

I don't know how Carol's "projected" became "rejected" either.  If it 
was an error of mine, I heartily apologize.  I do not like the idea 
of anyone "rewording" my posts, so I wouldn't do it to anyone else on 
purpose.  I do use copy and paste as we're supposed to, but one thing 
I also do is to neaten up (IMO) the formatting of the posts, and 
perhaps that's where the error got into the quote from Carol's post, 
though it's still hard for me to imagine myself changing "pro" 
to "re".  Oh well, sorry!!  In any case, if it helps, in the first 
post where I quoted that same passage (see no. 118500), I had it 
as "projected."  

Kim (hoping the List Elves don't find this post off-topic since I 
think it was necessary to set the record straight to all)







More information about the HPforGrownups archive