Harry learning from Snape (was: stopper death)

[dumbledore11214]

No: HPFGUIDX 114449


--- In HPforGrownups at yahoogroups.com, "dzeytoun" <dzeytoun at c...> 
wrote:
> I'm sorry SSS, but your attitude on this subject approaches being 
> reprehensible. 

Alla:

Ummm, I think that was uncalled for, Dzeytoun. But hey, that is just 
me.


Dzeytoun:

 Harry DOES NOT have to prove anything to Snape.  
> SNAPE MUST BE THE ONE TO CHANGE.  If he can't do it, then the 
> situation will just have to stay as it is.  Justice is MUCH more 
> important than efficiency or peace.
> 


Alla:

OK, forget about bringing Snape to justice for one minute, please.

Think about Harry and only about Harry.

So, the situation stays as it is. Harry hates Snape guts with 
passion.
Do you really think that Harry will be able to face Voldemort and 
survive with so much hate in his heart even if such person 
absolutely deserves it and I cannot concede that Snape deserves 
Harry's hate in ALL situations.

I think  that "Power Dark Lord knows not" will manifest itself 
towards Snape too.


Dzeytoun:
And if Dumbledore 
> really does feel that way, he has no business being in charge of a 
> lemonade stand, much less a school or a war.
> 
Alla:

Now, THAT I absolutely agree with.